Football Connect Four: the rules we ended up with
Columns are clubs, rows are categories, and a person at the table decides whether the name counts. Why we stopped letting the database referee our own game.
The club-and-category grid is the best football game format of the last few years, and it is usually played wrong. Here is the version we settled on, and the one rule that changed everything about it.
The board
The columns are clubs. The rows are something a player has to be: a nation, a position, a trophy he won. A disc falls to the lowest free square in the column you pick, so the question you have to answer is the club at the top of that column and the row the disc lands in — and the row changes as the column fills. Four discs in a line, across, down or diagonally, wins.
- Small board: four columns, four rows — one round over a coffee.
- Standard: five columns, four rows.
- Big board: six columns, four rows, for people who know too much.
- Turn the phone on its side and the board takes the whole screen.
The rule that changed everything
Our first version let the database referee. You typed a name, we looked it up, and if our records did not show that player at that club with that attribute, the answer was rejected. It was strict, it was consistent, and it was wrong roughly once a round — because no dataset of players is complete, and the gaps always seem to swallow somebody’s favourite answer. Being told you are wrong when you are right is the fastest way to make somebody close a game.
So we handed the whistle to the table. Now a name is put to the people in the room: our list says whether we recognise it, and then somebody presses Correct or Wrong. If everybody agrees that a left-back played a season on loan in Greece in 2014, the disc drops, and the fact that we have never heard of him is our problem, not theirs.
This is how the argument works in a café anyway. The phone keeps the score and draws the board; the people decide what counts.
Playing a bot
With nobody to judge, the bot judges itself against our list, which is the one place strictness belongs. There are three of them. The easy bot misses cells it should get. The medium bot plays the board properly but not the threats. The expert bot blocks a line before you have finished building it, and it will take a cheap cell to set up two threats at once — the same trick that wins the human version.
House rules worth adding
- A name is spent once per board. Saying it again is a miss, even in another column.
- Ten seconds to answer, once the other team starts counting out loud.
- No phones at the table except the one with the board on it.
- If the room genuinely cannot agree, the square is dead and the turn passes.