Where our player photos come from
Every photograph in Football Heritage comes from Wikimedia Commons with the photographer named in the app. Here is why we rebuilt the whole library to make that true.
A football game needs faces. The easy way to get them is to take them: there are millions of player photographs on the web, and almost all of them belong to a photographer or an agency who never agreed to be in your app. We started out with a library collected that way, and then we took it apart.
What was wrong with the easy way
A press photograph is somebody’s work. Using one without a licence is copyright infringement whether the app is free or not, and the people who own those photographs are organised about it. The risk is not a polite email — it is the app disappearing from the store on a Tuesday, with the accounts and the streaks still inside it.
Club crests are a second, separate problem. A crest is a trademark, and a game that prints one on a card can look like a game the club licensed. We had uploaded a few dozen of them.
What we did instead
- Every player photograph now comes from Wikimedia Commons, where the licence allows reuse as long as the photographer and the licence are named.
- A little over two thousand photographs are credited. Several hundred of them were matched to a free Commons version of the same player rather than deleted.
- A handful of famous players lost their photo because no free one exists. They appear without a face rather than with one we cannot use.
- The crests we had uploaded were removed. Clubs are drawn in the app instead, as a two-colour shield with the club’s short name.
- The importer now refuses any player photograph that does not come from Wikimedia, so the library cannot drift back.
Where the credits live
The licences ask that the photographer be named where the picture is used, so the app carries the list: Profile, then Settings, then Photo credits. It names every photographer whose work is in the game, with the licence beside it. It is a long list, and it should be.
If something should not be there
Mistakes are possible — a photograph attached to the wrong player, a credit that names the wrong person, a club that would rather not be drawn at all. Write to us and we will correct it or take it down. We would rather hear from you than from a lawyer, and so would you.